Return to the home page for MODIS Feature Identification Exercises

Feature Identification Exercises
Print Version
Case Example 4: Northeast U.S.

Return to Print Version Main Menu
Northeast U.S. Imagery
visible image of New England 10-Dec-01 after a snow storm with clouds and snow on the ground
SWIR 1.6-micrometer image of New England
SWIR 3.9-micrometer image of New England
IRWIN 11-micrometer image of New England

Page 1: Introduction

Vis image of New England with annotation indicating cumulus clouds over the ocean

This visible channel image was taken in the wake of an early, winter-like snowstorm that deposited several inches of snowfall over large portions of the northeastern U.S. The blue numbers indicate snow depth in inches. The scene in question appears to be composed primarily of a mixture of snow-covered ground, mixed forest, bare ground, open lakes, and rivers. Patches of cumulus clouds also appear off the coast as the less stable colder continental air is warmed and moistened by relatively warmer ocean waters.


Page 2: Identification Task:
Distinguishing Cloud from Snow on the Ground

Vis image of New England with annotation indicating question

The entire circled area appears covered by snow to some degree. Are there clouds in this scene as well? Locate areas of clouds and snow on the ground.

Hints:

The properties of the shortwave infrared channels should then help you determine whether clouds are present.

Shadows can also be useful in locating clouds, especially for middle- and higher-level clouds.

Once clouds are identified, the 11-micrometer image can help determine cloud height.


Answer:

Vis image of New England with annotation indicating low clouds

Additional examination of the scene indicates the presence of low clouds in some of the valleys and low-lying areas in eastern New York, Vermont, Massachusetts, and Connecticut. The visible channel suggests the presence of snow cover and possibly low clouds.

SWIR 1.6-micrometer image of New England with annotation indicating low clouds

A look at the 1.6-micrometer channel quickly points out that some of the valleys are covered by clouds, probably low clouds.

SWIR 3.9 micrometer image of New England with annotation indicating high ice clouds and low water clouds

In the absence of the 1.6-micrometer channel, the 3.9-micrometer channel will also indicate the presence of clouds and at the same time provide additional information on cloud phase (water vs. ice).

SWIR 3.9-micrometer image of New England with annotation indicating low water clouds and open water

Nearby bodies of open water also appear relatively warm/bright and could be mistaken for clouds.

SWIR 1.6- and 3.9-micrometer side by side image of New England with annotation indicating forested area in northeast New York

But both visible and 1.6-micrometer channels help rule out the presence of clouds over what is open water.

 

Page 3: Identification Task: Dark Features in Northeastern New York

Question: Despite observations of fresh snow cover across most of eastern New York, why do northeastern portions of the state take on the appearence of bare ground in the visible image? A: the area is heavily forested. B: The snow cover is older and possibly dirty. C: The snow cover melted in the time between the 12 UTC observations and the 15:54 UTC satellite overpass. D: The mountainous terrain reduces the snow's reflectivity.

Choose the best answer.

 

Answer:

Vis image over New England with annotations showing areas of forest

This area is heavily forested, and tree canopies typically mask the ground below. The relatively poorly reflective trees help to darken the underlying snow cover in the visible.

SWIR 1.6- and 3.9-micrometer side by side image of New England with annotation indicating bare ground, forest, and snow cover

Both the 1.6-micrometer and 3.9-micrometer channels help confirm the presence of snow cover. Recall that at 1.6 and 3.9 -micrometers, snow and ice surfaces are poorly reflective when compared to neighboring bare ground. We notice that the area in question appears darker than nearby bare ground along Lake Erie and on the New York side of the St. Lawrence River.

Vis image of New England with annotation indicating forest with question superimposed with answer A selected. Question: Why do northeastern portions of the state take on the appearence of bare ground in the visible image? A: the area is heavily forested. B: The snow cover is older and possibly dirty. C: The snow cover melted in the time between the 12 UTC observations and the 15:54 UTC satellite overpass. D: The mountainous terrain reduces the snow's reflectivity.


Answer B is incorrect, since we know the snow cover is relatively new.
Answer C is incorrect, since we can confirm the presence of snow or ice cover by examining either 1.6-or 3.9-micrometer imagery.
Answer D is incorrect, since snow would be apparent with the visible channel, even in rugged mountain terrain.


New England Summary

· The 1.6- and 3.9-micrometer channels confirmed the presence
  of clouds over a snow covered scene where discriminating snow
  cover from clouds using visible alone would have been
  nearly impossible

· The 1.6- and 3.9-micrometer channels confirmed the presence
  of snow cover within forested regions where the visible imagery
  had difficulty seeing the snow

Return to Print Version Main Menu